Will New HDTVs and 4K TVs Increase Tip-Over Injuries in 2014? HD Guru Investigates
The US Product Safety Commission reports 29% of the 17,000 TV tip-over injuries in 2011 requiring emergency medical treatment involved children under 9. Tip-over traumas cause the death of a child on average every three weeks (source: safekids.org).
Learn more about the problem and solutions after the break.
Deadly by design
An epidemic of TV tip-over injuries should be of great concern to set manufacturers. Inexplicably, instead of engineering solutions that improve set stability, new “form over function” pedestal designs from major manufacturers are even more unstable than the injury causing previous generation. One example: In 2013, Samsung changed from a traditional center pedestal to a boomerang-style design that extended the set’s full screen-width on its F8000 HDTV and F9000 Series sets. HD Guru found this new design to be significantly less stable than previous versions. If the outer edge of the pedestal exceeded the width of the TV stand (the furniture that you place the TV on), the set would easily tip over. In fact, three professional TV reviewers that we know of ended up accidentally tipping their review units. For its 2014 models, Samsung corrected the issue by redesigning its sets’ pedestals to be closer to the screen’s center. However, many new TVs coming from Sony and LG in 2014 abandon the legacy center pedestal in favor of feet extending out front and back located at or near the screen’s edge. These new designs also create a potential tip-over hazard. Sony (see top photo) plans to start selling 12 televisions with this new stand design in March. As for LG, its entire 2014 line of big-screen HDTVs plans will have similar, wide-spaced feet (see 2nd photo).
Retail Me Not
Along with spindly pedestals, another problem increasing the likelihood of tip-overs is a lack of detail in the TV stand dimension specs coming from retailers and stand manufacturers. A number of TV stands sold by Best Buy and other dealers do not have a rectangular top surface. For example, check out the picture below of one of Best Buy’s best-selling stands, the Init model NT-MG1158. The specs on the company’s website state that this model will hold up to a 60-inch TV and list its dimensions as 58 inches wide and 20 inches deep. However, those specs are for the maximum width and depth of the stand’s non-rectangular top.
How will Best Buy’s sketchy specs create problems? Here’s one scenario. Sony’s forthcoming 60-inch KDL-60W850B requires a TV stand with minimum depth of 12 5/7-inches to support it. Can the Init NT-MG1158 accommodate Sony’s new HDTV? There’s really no way to know without breaking out a tape measure and physically measuring the stand’s top surface. Two weeks ago we notified a Best Buy spokesperson about the lack of detailed TV stand dimensions on the company’s website. We also asked if it plans to provide more thorough specs to help consumers avoid purchasing stands that won’t properly support the new TVs from LG and Sony. To date we have not received a response. We also located the Init website and called its customer service number. (Init is a Best Buy house brand owned and operated by the company along with other brands such as Insignia, Dynex and Rocketfish.) The customer service rep was not able to provide detailed top dimensions for the Init NT-MG1158.
Sanus, a large manufacturer of TV stands and mounts, also fails to provide a complete set dimensions for a number of its non-rectangular-topped models (drawing above). Of the three models we checked out at random on its website (BFAV344, BFV 53 and BFV48), none provided sufficient measurements (both minimum and maximum width along with depth for the stand’s top surface). HD Guru asked a Sanus representative about the issue and whether the company planned to update its product specifications. Their response appears at the end of the article. Ironically, Sanus financed a TV tip-over study conducted by safekids.org, so the company is obviously keenly aware of the issue.
There are a number of precautions that new TV buyers can undertake to eliminate or reduce the risk of a tip-over. If you plan to install your set on a TV stand, first measure the maximum width and depth of the feet or pedestal and then measure the stand’s top surface. If the TV doesn’t fit, meaning its pedestal or feet won’t be 100% supported, do not place it on the stand—you will need to return it for a larger model. (If an LCD TV does tip over, its screen will most likely crack. This will render it worthless as panel replacement parts and labor costs typically exceed the replacement cost for the TV.) A number of devices are also available to help prevent TV tip-overs. Inexpensive straps sold by Sanus and others attach to a TV stand to prevent forward tip-overs. These are useless for preventing rearward tip-overs, however.
A better option is a solid bar that supports the TV in both directions. One such device made by Peerless is its AV ACSTA1-US Stabilis Home Safety Kit for LCD and Plasma Screens/32-60 Black , it sells on Amazon.com for $20.99. While we have not used this safety kit, we are very familiar with Peerless mounts and have always found the company’s products to have exceptional build quality. A better and safer alternative to TV stands is to hang your set on a compatible wall mount. (Unfortunately, only 25% of TVs are wall-mounted according to safekid.org.) Carefully follow all manufacturer instructions and anchor the mount by securely fastening it to wall studs (never use sheet rock toggle-type bolts) using the screws that came with the mount. For anyone who is not familiar with carpentry, we recommend paying for a professional installation.
A Final Word
We at HD Guru would like to see more dealer/installer awareness of the TV tip-over issue, especially if they plan to sell the 2014 Sony and LG models mentioned earlier. We also urge TV stand makers to revise their specifications to accurately reflect the true dimensions of their products. To learn more more about TV tip-overs, read the latest reports on the issue at cpsc.gov here and here and from Safekids.org here.
The following comment was emailed to HD Guru by Tim Alessi, Director – New Product Development at LG Electronics USA: “Product safety is a top priority at LG. Most of our 2014 line of 1080p LCD sets use stands with feet placed towards the outer part of the screen. All of these sets have been UL approved for safety and we state in the owner’s manual to make sure the stand is strong and large enough to support the TV securely. We provide consumers with weight and dimension specs both with and without the stand. There are also pictures of the sets on our website and spec sheets which can be downloaded that include this information. We hope this information provides consumers with the necessary tools to make an informed purchase decision for both the TV and the type of furniture it will be placed on.”
The following comment was emailed to HD Guru by Michael Applen, Social Media & P.R. Strategist for Milestone AV Technologies (the parent company of Sanus)
“We have always recommended mounting your TV to the wall in the studs using a TV wall mount. Mounting on the wall is best way to ensure a flat screen TV is secure and will not hurt anyone. Regarding the specifications of our furniture, we are working with our design and engineering teams to modify and update our current technical drawing sheets to include all angled areas on the furniture top of the models that are not standard in an effort to inform the consumer if the furniture will in fact be large enough for their new TV.
We hope that these new feet are not a safety issue, but will continue to monitor this possible issue and stay ahead of curve on combating accidental TV tip-overs.”
Have a question for the HD Guru?
Copyright ©2014 HD Guru Inc. All rights reserved. HDGURU is a registered trademark